Lemons and Lemonade
Okay, so, Fred Phelps and his family of hateful bigots are getting a lot of press for their planned appearance at (or near?) the San Diego Comic Con. The man lives for attention and confrontation. If you see him there, don’t sneer, don’t scream, don’t confront, don’t point and laugh–DON’T ACKNOWLEDGE. Ignore, ignore, ignore, ignore, ignore…
EXCEPT! We need some help in the form of a time-keeper or two, letting us know exactly how long the patron saint of backwards thinking and his family manage to stand and scream in the California sun. Then, by all means, do stare–at your watch! Make a note of what time it is and alert the internet that they’re there/still there. (But do it quietly and from a polite distance, will you?) Go get yourself a cold drink and check back every now and then until we have an approximate time count. Like… here would be good. Or on Twitter, with the hashtag #godlovesbatman
Why? Because in the spirit of love, we are pledging to donate $50 to amfAR if Phelps and his crew actually show up (often they don’t) and $10 an hour additional to amfAR for every hour they stay. And we’ll make our donation in Fred’s name.
We’d love you to join us.
(And we’d really love to be able to post a tally of how much we’ve raised.)
Repost far and wide, my pretties.
EDITED TO ADD:
- We’ll be donating to amfAR, but Sam and Ginny have both suggested the Human Rights Campaign. Either seems appropriate.
- Looks like the WBC is only scheduled for 45 minutes. (Lightweights!) If that’s the case, we’ll round up to $100–but times are tough and you shouldn’t feel like you have to do the same or not participate. $7.50 is better than nothing. $57.50 is peachy and cute.
- There seems to be some confusion–you don’t need to be at SDCC to pledge. We’re doing an online donation via this link.
EDITED ONCE AGAIN:
- I’m told the HRC is quite controversial within the LGBT community for their treatment of the “T” part of the LGBT. Dirk Deppey suggests the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force instead (Click the big pink DONATE button on the upper right). We have chosen amfAR, but honestly, folks, there are a ton of appropriate charities from the CBLDF (the WBC folks are fond of litigation, as it happens, and they are accusing us of idol worship) to smaller local groups like UCan in Chicago. (With any charitable organization, do your research.) What matters is that you take a message of hate and you turn it into a LOVING ACTION. Get it? Some assholes go and scream about God’s wrath and BAM! somewhere on the other side of the world, somebody gets a pill they need that they might not have gotten otherwise.
- Another suggestion I loved was to match the WBC’s time with your time. So if they spend 45 minutes screaming and yelling, maybe you spend 45 minutes making phone calls to your elected officials making clear your position of support for LGBT civil rights initiatives. Or you volunteer for an hour at a food bank. Or whatever. Get creative; you people are amazing.


This is a great idea. I’ve had the misfortune to have to see these clowns outside an Elton John concert in Tulsa. This is a great idea to counter their hate!
[...] Source: Kellysue.com [...]
I wish everyone taking part in this venture the best of luck, and may whatever charities benefit to the fullest. I’d forgotten about these unspeakable specimens, and the evangelists who’ve just arrived in my neighbourhood for their annual “Gathering” don’t seem quite so bad…
I hate those bast… in a very Christian way. Kudos for this. I’m nowhere near to help in the effort, but I’ll spread the word.
Yay! I love your plan, too bad I can’t help from the other side of the country.
[...] It’s not a confrontation, or a protest. Instead, Kelly Sue and Matt and everyone else who is interested are making donations to amfAR, the H… [...]
Oh, this is genius. Donating the money in their names… that could be used as a protest methods in so many other arenas as well. Snubbing and giving all at once, and no one gets hurt. I’m impressed.
Neil Gaiman just retweeted your article; and with nearly a million five people following him, I’m guessing that’s going to help your goal out quite a little bit.
Cheers!
Exxxcelllent…(said in best Mr Burns voice)
The existence of the Phelps family is proof for the non-existence of God: If there were a God, and He heard the lies and filth that these people are spewing in His name, He would surely strike them dead on the spot.
I’ve donated to several worthy charities in Fred’s name over the years. Ah, he’s such a putz.
I’ll watch here to see how long he stays at Comic Con, and donate to amfAR this time around.
[...] each hour they stay. That’s just what DeConnick and her husband Matt Fraction have planned, adding that donations to the Human Rights Campaign or CBLDF would also be a good choice, you don’t have to be at [...]
[...] Sue DeConnick has planned a similar fundraiser where participants donate directly to amfAR and the Human Rights [...]
[...] Writer Kelly Sue DeConnick and Matt Fraction (and I imagine by this time others) are turning the planned protest of Comic-Con [...]
[...] writer Kelly Sue DeConnick has an excellent antidote in her God Loves Batman initiative, and I highly encourage you to [...]
Oh thank you, THANK YOU for turning this bigot’s BS into a source of something positive! I am retweeting and posting to the Facebook minions..
THANK YOU!
What a revolting creature! Good luck with your project!
[...] There’s a fundraising match challenge for the Westboro Baptist Church protest at Comic-Con. They’re taking donations and soliciting timekeepers. [...]
[...] – but the best idea came from comic writers Kelly Sue DeConnick and Matt Fraction and their GodLovesBatman initiative. They intend to donate $100 to AIDS research if the Phelps clan makes their scheduled 45 [...]
Donating to Human Rights Campaign will become appropriate once they start fully supporting trans-inclusive policies, but until then it will not be. Apart from that, great idea!
I will donate 10$ to amFAR 10$ to human rights if that’s a plan too. And if my bank account is healthy I will donate more after comic-con. (I will be going).
Thank you for doing this, and for reminding me to ignore these pricks, which will be difficult for me.
[...] kind of neat is happening as a result of the protest, though. Check out #godlovesbatman on Twitter [more info here]. Thanks to @melsh for titling the [...]
Yeah they protested our school last semester because we’re a military school. (The funny bit is that only 1/3 of the cadets actually join the military so it’s more of a “military style school’) But they never actually filed the proper forms so they weren’t allowed on campus!
The worst part is how they instigate fights, sue the people/institutions and that’s how they make money. It’s deplorable.
If I had more than $40 in my account I would donate (sadly it’s all budgeted out) but keep up the good work!
I quit collecting comics when the cover price went up to 40 cts., and consider SDCC a horrible parody of the worst things that have happened to “fandom” since the commercial interests took over media/comics conventions. But for all those reasons not to be there, I’m nonetheless glad that you’re turning these blasphemous morons’ presence into goodness. Thanks for doing this.
As a Quaker, I’ll make my donation to the American Friends Service Committee, people engaged for decades in a bunch of actual Christian activities in which other folks are welcome to join: the anti-Phelps (bizarro-Phelps?) folks of the Christian tradition. I’ll send the good wishes of the SDCC attendees along when I do so.
This thrills me to no end that people use what could be a bad destructive force and turn it around for good. The Phelps have been a thorn in my side for years – they actually showed up at my alma mater last year on their way back to KS after `protesting` at Ft. Hood.
Thanks so much for doing this. Responding to hate with love is the only way to quell it.
[...] Sue DeConnick posted on her blog a plan she and her husband, Matt Fraction, have to turn the tables on the WBC. While she highlights [...]
[...] Alright, as soon as I have confirmation that they’re gone, we’ll go ahead and make our donation. [...]
[...] Dear Lord, save us from your followers: Fred Phelps is going to Comicon. [...]